Thanksgiving football isn’t what it used to be.
In fact, for the most part, it just isn’t anymore.
This year’s schedule will feature only two Northeast teams suiting up on Thanksgiving morning. The game that will never disappear, Northeast-Central, will of course be played. Those two schools care more about that game than anything else, and that’s why Charlie Martin Memorial Stadium will be rocking on Thanksgiving morning.
The other will be Frankford vs. Simon Gratz. You have to hand it to Frankford for keeping the tradition alive. After their former rival North Catholic went away, the Pioneers’ brass has made sure to find a foe every year. It’s been more than a few opponents – Boys Latin, Roman Catholic, Samuel Fels, Conwell-Egan, Simon Gratz – but the main thing is the Frankford football community has something to do before Thanksgiving every year.
Archbishop Ryan and George Washington were scheduled to play on Thanksgiving, but a rough season with injuries, coupled with a long layoff caused the game to be called off by the Raiders.
Judge-Lincoln ended its rivalry on Thanksgiving after the 2023 game.
The city has done a better job than the rest of the world holding onto Thanksgiving football, but the early start to the season means an earlier end to the season. Some teams play their final game before Halloween, so keeping teams interested, active and healthy for about a month for one meaningless game (in the standings) is a lot to ask.
This is a product of being in the PIAA. If you want to qualify for the state playoffs, you have to play seeding games in early November. That means teams that don’t make the playoffs will have long layoffs.
And if you do happen to advance, the Thanksgiving game is just an obstacle you have to get through before you play for a state championship.
It’s hard to imagine Northeast-Central ever going away, but it’s not hard to imagine it being an anomaly in the next decade or so.
That doesn’t mean old heads can’t long for the good old days.
This Thanksgiving, with not many games to choose from, let’s take a look back at the past by ranking the best Thanksgiving rivalries for our schools.
We’ll only do the major ones, we won’t do one-offs, just the traditional biggies. Each school gets their main rival.
So grab a drumstick and a six pack, and let’s remember the best Thanksgiving rivalries in Northeast Philly history.
5. Dougherty-Olney
As a Dougherty grad, it pains me to put this at the bottom of the list. The game was played at Olney, which wasn’t in Northeast Philly, and the Trojans weren’t very good most years. Dougherty owned the series, and Olney typically didn’t bring a big crowd to the game. Still, it was way better than when Dougherty bailed on Olney and started playing Kennedy-Kenrick on Thanksgiving. I’ve always believed Thanksgiving should be Catholic vs. Public.
4. Judge-Lincoln
This one would be higher if the series wasn’t so lopsided. The Railsplitters were coming on before the game was canceled after the 2023 game, but Judge hadn’t lost a game since 1989. This game wasn’t much to watch on the field, but it was a great game to be at. Both schools brought out fans, and it had a great atmosphere. This game was extremely important to both schools, and even though most games weren’t close, every Lincoln kid thought “this is the year we’ll beat Judge.” The game was just as important to the Crusaders. Wish it was still around.
3. Ryan-Washington
This is the game I typically went to because it largely produced the best football. Traditionally, these two teams were among the best in the area, and there were many times over the years where this game featured the best team in the Public League vs. the best team in the Catholic League. The games weren’t always close, but like Judge-Lincoln, this game has an incredible atmosphere. They made the right call nixing it this year, but I hope it returns better than ever in 2027.
2. Northeast-Central
The first four were pretty easy. This one was the hardest. One of the top two couldn’t finish at the top, and I know Northeast folks won’t be happy about this. This is one of the oldest Thanksgiving game with the first game being played on Thanksgiving in 1896. The Vikings have dominated the series in recent years before falling last year. Overall, the Vikings have a two-game lead. The biggest reason for this falling to No. 2 is it’s not as special anymore. These two teams meet every year before Thanksgiving, sometimes they meet again in the playoffs, making the Thanksgiving game the third meeting between the schools. Also, I’m partial to Public vs. Catholic games. This game could easily be No. 1 on the list.
No. 1 North Catholic-Frankford
This game always had the most buzz. It was the earliest game of the year, so you could go to this game and still be home before watching the Lions get beat, and it seemed to have the best neighborhood rivalry. What also made this game fun was that it was always close. Even when Frankford had the best team in the Public League and the Falcons were struggling, North would always show up on Thanksgiving. Both teams would pack the stands with fans, Frankford still does it, but no matter who the Pioneers play, it’s never the same as North. ••
